In my opinion, Marshon should be All-Rookie first team. No way Shumpert should be 1st team. Marshon is so much more valuable to the Nets than Shumpert is to the Knicks. Although Shumpert is clearly better defensively, Marshon is much better offensively, which is much more important. The main factor of determining how good a player is is by their offensive contributions, not their defensive. When people grade how good Melo is, no one cares about how bad a defensive player he is. They just care about his offensive talents.
Anyway, I made a video as a tribute to his great rookie year.
Here's the link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kAbertetkTk