We've argued and argued, but no one has put up a poll yet. So let's get a sense of where the community is at. You can vote based on the long-term or short-term consequences; whatever is more important to you. I included Augustin in the poll because I believe (if it goes through) that we'll get him or some reasonably similar player.
I see that I need more words to publish this, so
If the trade goes through as described (Favors, Harris, the GS 1st round pick and our 2011 1st round pick for Melo and D.J. Augustin), is it a good trade or a bad trade for the Nets?
Good for Nets (78 votes)
Even trade (54 votes)
Bad for Nets (144 votes)
276 total votes